Chapter 11
Dawn Staley
We're Not Changing. How Dawn Staley built South Carolina on a named job, a defensive identity, and players who bought the role, in her own words.
Chris Collinsworth · · 12 min read
Dallas. March 31, 2023. Iowa 77, South Carolina 73. They had been unbeaten. They were not, anymore.
After the game she said she was not rewriting the gym.
"We've won a lot of basketball games doing it this way. We're not changing."1
That's the gym. Not a new coverage because a loss stung. Defend. Rebound. Play the role you were given. The next year they started five new players and went 38-0.
Dawn Staley, in her own words. From press conferences, The Players' Tribune, ESPN, the Post and Courier, The State, and the people who sat in that locker room. Sources at the end.
#We're not changing
The identity was already the argument. Lisa Bluder, Iowa's coach, had called rebounding against them a bar fight. Staley would not let that sit as a description of her team.
"We're not bar fighters. We're not thugs. We're not monkeys. We're not street fighters. This team exemplifies how you need to approach basketball on the court and off the court. … You may not like how we play the game, you may not like it — that's the way we play. That's the way I coach. I'm not changing."1
She told the room they had found success in it, and some days you end up on the losing side of the stick. "But guess what? We live to see another day. We live to see the comeback next year and try to do this again because I'm not changing."1
A year later the starting five was gone. The identity was not. She told David Cloninger of the Post and Courier what the new locker room sounded like compared with the last one.
"A doctorate program … and daycare. Our locker room sounds like daycare. It's so much talking, about nothing."2
They still won. She stopped fighting the noise. "In the beginning of the season, we would just say, 'Be quiet!' Now it's just who they are. It's their identity. We really don't fight that battle. We just put our earplugs in."2 She told Payton Titus of The State the same thing in fewer words. "We just put our earplugs in and keep it moving."3
That's not a soft gym. That's a coach who will change how she talks and will not change what the gym stands on. Krzyzewski adapts the teaching to who walked in. Staley does that with the volume. The job on the floor stays. Defend. Rebound. Outwork. If a player has to stop and ask whether they still have to do that after a Final Four loss, she already knows the answer.
Assistant Jolette Law told Cloninger what that looked like in June. They tried to add a zone, a press. No. "This season has taught all of us: The word is, 'Simplify.'"2 Staley, on the same team: "You have to figure out what we can actually integrate, what they're going to give us."2
Complexity isn't wrong. It's expensive. They scrapped what the roster couldn't hold and kept the thing it could.
#Defense is a decision
She does not recruit defense as a skill you either have or you don't.
Before a Sweet 16 in Greensboro she told a room of reporters what she looks for.
"We don't necessarily just look at someone that can be a great defender. I think defense is a decision. You either are going to do it or not. It's not really a skill set."4
They've been defending as long as she's been a coach, she said, "because we really didn't know offensively what that always looked like."4 The freshmen who became Boston, Beal, Cooke, came in with one attitude: do anything to get on the floor. The older ones laid the foundation. Then the grade.
"I think when people come to the University of South Carolina, they know they're going to have to play defense or else the likelihood of them playing a whole lot is slim to none."4
That's three of the four questions without a worksheet. What am I responsible for? Stops. How? Make it hard. What happens if I don't? You sit. A player who has to stop and ask whether tonight is a defending night is already late.
When the shots weren't falling, they didn't hunt a new identity. "That's who we are. I think when you have an identity, and we created a defensive identity, and that is to make it really hard." Her players, she said, don't want to be the one with the lapse. "They hold each other to that standard of giving everything that they have, and it becomes contagious, and you don't want to be the one."4
Pete Iacobelli of the Associated Press put the same Sweet 16 in numbers. Howard scored 21, the lowest total ever allowed in an NCAA Tournament game, without a field goal in the second quarter. Miami scored 33. Why the contract has to hold on those nights: "because when we've shot the way we've shot the last two games, or four out of five, or whatever it is, you never know, you know?"5
Tokyo went on the floor in Columbia. Amna Subhan wrote it up for NCAA.com in 2023: a three-player switch, sometimes four, that she brought back from coaching the Olympic team. "If a college team is able to execute it, you could have one of the best defenses in college basketball," Staley said. "It's pretty neat for us to be able to seamlessly defend that way."6 It only works if five people are on the same page in a second. She told Subhan they were. "We're linked at the heart. They really respect and love and, generally, want the best for each individual on our team and they show it in their play."6
Linked at the heart is chemistry language. On the floor it is a shared why. Nobody has to think whose mismatch this is.
#Only what you do best
Depth is not a luxury in that gym. It is the system.
Before the 2021-22 season she had sixteen players and forty minutes. She told Augusta Stone of The State she was going to call the parents first. "We'll call them … just let them know, 'Your daughter is going to go through a major change of playing a lot, not playing or playing a little.' And that's going to rock them a little bit. But we just need you to be parents, support them and see them through this."7
Then the job, in one sentence.
"If you're disciplined and doing what you do best, it should present you with carving out some time to get out on the floor. If you aren't, I mean, you've got to get to the back of the line to try to work it back, but by then it's too late."7
If you try to do the thing the kid next to you is best at, you get in line. Chapter 1 is why that works. A named job is checkers. Five people trying to be the point guard is Hick's Law in a huddle.
She told Meredith Cash of Business Insider she had already lived it. USA Basketball. Superstars on the bench. "I usually give the worst-case scenario — you may not play. You've got to hit them over the head and then you have to explain to them, this is what you signed up for, so you can't be a distraction."8
"If you don't like your role, you've got to fake it, because you can't be a distraction for the people that are totally bought in [or] you're going to look a lot different than everybody else. You're going to stick out like a sore thumb."8
She was a two-time national player of the year at Virginia. On the Olympic team she started once. "I sit here today as a three-time Olympic gold medalist. I only started in one, but you would never know. You would never know." When she got her minutes, you remembered her. "That is what being part of a team that has one goal in mind [entails]; you find your role and you play it to the best of your ability."8
She asked that roster for one year. "The fact that we're here at the Final Four means that there was buy-in. There was total buy-in."8 Two nights later they beat UConn 64-49. Destanni Henderson scored 26. Aliyah Boston was the Most Outstanding Player. They doubled the Huskies on the glass.
The 2024 title game was the same contract with a younger roster. Thirty-seven bench points to zero. Afterward she walked through the names. Chloe Kitts up and down, then a good game. MiLaysia Fulwiley, a household name, coming off the bench, maybe less than twenty minutes, who could have had the ball somewhere else every trip. Sania Feagin, a junior, probably started less than ten times, crucial that night.
"I hold her to her standard, I hold her to her personal and individual standard to sometimes that equates to six minutes, or five minutes or less. And it doesn't feel good, but in order for us to do what we do today means she's got to meet her standard. And we don't sacrifice that."9
That's the grade. Not a vibe. Minutes follow the job. The job does not follow the minutes.
#A disciplined person can do anything
She wrote her own origin in The Players' Tribune in 2015, before the first banner.
"I live by two mottos: A disciplined person can do anything. Dare to do what you don't want to get what you do want."10
She never wanted to be a coach. She was a short, determined girl from Philly. Basketball was her life. Collegiate, professional, national. Then Temple, 2000, still playing in the WNBA, a struggling program. "I found quickly that when you have a connection and a shared belief with your team — when you share a vision — you can accomplish a lot together. That was the beauty of those Temple years."10
South Carolina in 2008 was the next hard thing. The program hadn't been to the NCAA Tournament in five years. UConn, Tennessee, Stanford, Baylor, Notre Dame had the recruits. "That needed to change. Challenge accepted."10
She told The State why she left Temple. Eight years. Six NCAA appearances. First and second round, over and over. "I thought we got Temple to a place where we topped off, and it comes down to who you're able to recruit. In a place like Temple, you have to want to be at Temple. … And I just really got tired of losing in the first and second round."11
Eric Hyman, the athletic director who hired her, had to go to Philadelphia to get the real conversation. Starbucks. Interrupted every five minutes. Everybody knew her. He thought she was worth the fight with the board.11
The secret, she wrote, is not a set.
"If there were ever a secret to being a great coach, that's it: the connection. I need to have a personal relationship with each player. I, just like they do, have to be invested."10
You can't ask a player to let you in if you don't. "At the collegiate level, there are many things the players need to learn, and they can't learn everything at once. It's too much for them to grasp. It starts with instilling the discipline to work hard and to find balance." Everybody wants to be an Olympian. Not everyone will put the work in every day. "I have to make these players believe that my vision is good for them. It's going to hurt, it's going to be uncomfortable, but it's good for you. Everybody gets the same treatment — whether they have WNBA potential or not."10
That's the Philly point guard, still. In 2018 she opened another Players' Tribune essay on the railroad tracks around the North Philly housing projects. They hand-painted the lines. They made baskets out of crates. "We had to hand paint every line. We had to create everything."12 She got a scholarship to Virginia. Culture shock. She didn't go to parties. She went to the rec center and got shots up. "That was how I survived."12
She thinks about that now in Columbia. "I think I create an option for young Black women." She is aware of what her success represents, and of what her failure would. "Black women in coaching positions are held to higher standards — especially because there are so few opportunities."12 Her mother left South Carolina at thirteen. Staley came back. "She left South Carolina because of the racial divide. I came back with a hope to bridge it."12
The discipline is not a slogan on the wall. It is how a kid from a crate rim builds a program that was not supposed to live with Tennessee and UConn.
#Cleveland
April 7, 2024. South Carolina 87, Iowa 75. Thirty-eight and zero. New starting five. Same gym.
Caitlin Clark scored 30. Raven Johnson took the assignment after the first quarter. Kamilla Cardoso had 15 and 17 rebounds. The bench outscored Iowa's 37-0. Staley cried when they handed her the trophy.
"It was emotional for me because of how it ended last year. I'll leave that there."9
She was emotional at the start of the game because she didn't want last year again. She was handling it in real time, not afterward. "I had a little bit of PTSD, and I addressed it in real time." The load of an undefeated season, every player, every staff member. "It's a heavy load to be undefeated, to finish the job."9
The night before, she had told the same room the 38-0 didn't feel like 38-0. "As much as you bring up like an undefeated season, it doesn't feel like it because, I mean, we've played some bad basketball that made it feel like we lost." The staff had to pinch themselves. "Deep down we see what our shortcomings are every single day."13
That's a coach who will not let a record become the identity. The identity is still the decision on the next possession.
After the win she said they had quietly done it the right way. "We find the right pieces to help us. We really do things the right way. We're very disciplined in how we approach basketball." Forever indebted to the game. Respectful of it, of opponents, of the history. "We're going to keep doing what we're doing the right way, whether we are the popular or unpopular successful programs in the country."9
She does not coach for the trophy they hand the coach. Three days earlier, picking up AP Coach of the Year, she said it without a ball in the gym.
"I don't coach to win awards. I really don't. I'm very, very satisfied with being a dream merchant for our players. That's it."14
On the floor in Cleveland the dream had a job attached. Have a plan when you catch it. Don't hold it more than a second. Give it to Kamilla. Knock down a three when you're open. "Very, very simple."13 She has not always been that way. "I've had to lay down my religion a few times" at halftime. You deliver the message the way this team can receive it, "because ultimately you just want them to get the message. Sometimes we as coaches mess up the message with how angry we can get."13
Speak their vernacular. Then they deliver. The coach can still play chess. Scout Clark, change the matchup, call the timeout when it dwindles to five. The players already know the job. Stops. Roles. The standard you don't sacrifice for six minutes.
She told the 2015 essay what she hoped for those young women. National championships, yes. Lessons that stay. "But more than anything, I just hope they have a passion for something — that they find their passion and live it."10 Nine years later the passion had a 38 next to a 0, and she was still selling the same two mottos. A disciplined person can do anything. Dare to do what you don't want, to get what you do.
#Notes
- Alexa Philippou and Andrea Adelson, "Dawn Staley to critics: South Carolina 'not changing' its style," ESPN, April 1, 2023 (updated April 5, 2023). https://www.espn.com/womens-college-basketball/story/_/id/36025649/dawn-staley-critics-south-carolina-not-changing-style ↩
- David Cloninger, "Dawn's Daycare: New-look, new-approach Gamecocks just keep winning," The Post and Courier, March 8, 2024. https://www.postandcourier.com/sports/carolina/gamecocks-womens-basketball-sec-tournament-undefeated/article_d75c1012-dc9b-11ee-9c89-e78ef17ea31b.html ↩
- Payton Titus, "Gamecocks finish regular season undefeated again. Why this time feels different," The State, March 3, 2024. https://www.thestate.com/sports/college/university-of-south-carolina/usc-womens-basketball/article286133126.html ↩
- Dawn Staley, Sweet 16 media conference, Greensboro, March 24, 2022 (ASAP Sports transcript). http://www.asapsports.com/show_interview.php?id=174638 ↩
- Pete Iacobelli, "No. 1 South Carolina leaning on its defense in NCAA tourney," Associated Press, March 24, 2022, via The Seattle Times. https://www.seattletimes.com/sports/no-1-south-carolina-leaning-on-its-defense-in-ncaa-tourney/ Also: https://apnews.com/article/march-madness-sports-college-basketball-greensboro-south-carolina-19b779dced0539cedc4e2baaec8011b4 ↩
- Amna Subhan, "The keys to South Carolina basketball's dominant defense," NCAA.com, March 31, 2023. https://www.ncaa.com/news/basketball-women/article/2023-03-31/keys-south-carolina-basketballs-dominant-defense ↩
- Augusta Stone, "Why Dawn Staley has calls to make to players' parents before USC's first game," The State, November 5, 2021. https://www.thestate.com/sports/college/university-of-south-carolina/usc-womens-basketball/article255430696.html ↩
- Meredith Cash, "Dawn Staley took an Olympic approach to South Carolina's season. Now the Gamecocks are in the Final Four," Business Insider, April 1, 2022. https://www.businessinsider.com/dawn-staley-olympic-strategy-south-carolina-leads-to-final-four-2022-3 ↩
- Dawn Staley, national championship postgame media conference, Cleveland, April 7, 2024 (ASAP Sports transcript; South Carolina 87, Iowa 75). http://www.asapsports.com/show_interview.php?id=196165 ↩
- Dawn Staley, "The Secret," The Players' Tribune, June 15, 2015. https://www.theplayerstribune.com/articles/dawn-staley-south-carolina-coach ↩
- Payton Titus, "'Dawn was worth it': Inside South Carolina's quest to hire Dawn Staley as WBB coach," The State, March 12, 2024. https://www.thestate.com/sports/college/university-of-south-carolina/usc-womens-basketball/article286326990.html ↩
- Dawn Staley, "Where Are All the Black Coaches?," The Players' Tribune, November 28, 2018. https://www.theplayerstribune.com/articles/dawn-staley-black-coaches ↩
- Dawn Staley, national championship pregame media conference, Cleveland, April 6, 2024 (ASAP Sports transcript). http://www.asapsports.com/show_interview.php?id=196124 Also: Zach Koons, "Dawn Staley Details Why Caitlin Clark Must Win a Championship to Be the GOAT," Sports Illustrated, April 6, 2024. https://www.si.com/college/2024/04/06/south-carolina-dawn-staley-caitlin-clark-championship-goat ↩
- Dawn Staley, AP Women's Coach of the Year press conference, Cleveland, April 4, 2024 (ASAP Sports transcript). http://www.asapsports.com/show_conference.php?id=196028 ↩
