Chapters5. Dick and Tony Bennett

Chapter 5

Dick and Tony Bennett

First Comes Discipline. How a father built the pack line and a son carried it to a national title.

Chris Collinsworth · · updated · 11 min read

Before every Virginia practice, a student manager got down on the floor with a roll of blue tape.

Dick Bennett and Tony Bennett, in their own words. From press conferences, clinics, podcasts, a webinar, and the players who lived inside the pack line. Sources at the end. Same system, same words, thirty years apart.


#Clintonville to Charlottesville

Dick Bennett grew up in Clintonville, Wisconsin, and went to Ripon College. Then he coached high school basketball for eleven seasons, at schools that included West Bend and Eau Claire Memorial, and won 168 games. His 1975-76 Eau Claire Memorial team went 22-3 and finished second in the state.1

He has never talked about those years like a stepping stone. On a podcast decades later, he summed up the job in one line. "All there was to the job was a love of the game and a love for the kids."2

His teaching came from somewhere close to home. In 2000 he told reporters he used to watch Vince Lombardi's practices and go to his games in Green Bay. "His method of teaching was repetition and simplicity. Do few things, but do them well."3 That sentence explains everything that follows in this chapter.

In 1976 he took over at Wisconsin-Stevens Point, an NAIA school, and won 173 games in nine seasons. His 1983-84 team went 28-4 and finished national runner-up, and he was named NAIA Coach of the Year.1 Then he went to Wisconsin-Green Bay, which had gone 4-24 the year before he arrived.1 His Green Bay teams usually weren't the best athletes on the floor, and the defense had to change. Fran Fraschilla put it simply. "The pack line defense was born out of necessity."4

He took Green Bay to its first NCAA Tournament in 1991, then moved to Wisconsin, and in 2000 the Badgers made the Final Four for the first time in 59 years.1,4 People called it ugly. At the Final Four he answered that the same way he answered everything. "If it means it's ugly, then so be it."5

Tony grew up in those gyms, and for a while he wanted nothing to do with coaching. "My father is one of the wisest, humblest guys I know, but he was just so intense," he told Yahoo Sports. He watched the losing streaks and the roller coaster, and he said, "I swore off it."6

He could play. He was Wisconsin's Mr. Basketball, then played for his father at Green Bay from 1989 to 1992, where he finished as the conference's career leader in points and assists and made 49.7 percent of his threes, an NCAA record.7 The Charlotte Hornets took him in the second round in 1992, and a foot injury ended his NBA career after three seasons.7,8 A stint as a player-coach in New Zealand, and then a season working for his father at Wisconsin in 1999-2000, changed his mind. "The experience of being around that taught me, 'I think I want to do this.'"6

He followed his father to Washington State as an assistant and took over the program in 2006. A team picked to finish last in the Pac-10 went 26-8.8 Virginia hired him in 2009, and he won 364 games there, more than anyone in school history.8

When he's asked where it all comes from, he doesn't make it complicated. "My coaching philosophy is shaped a lot on what I learned playing for my dad."9


#Do few things, but do them well

Dick Bennett's whole career is a short list. On a 2020 coaching webinar he said it as plainly as I've ever heard a coach say it.

"Whatever you do, you have to do all the time. I was always a system coach. Scouting didn't mean as much to me."10

Tony said the same thing in his own words before his third season at Virginia. "You gotta choose what you want to work on, because there's just not enough time to do everything."11

On defense, the responsibility is one idea. Stay in the gap, inside the line. Tony explained it to the student paper in his second season. "It's packed in so your guys can't have alleys to the basket."12 Years later he described the system the same way. "It's more of a team system. You have to rely on people being in the help position, in the gaps."13

On offense, Dick gave every player a label before he gave him a play. In his blocker-mover offense, every player is one or the other. One set of coaching notes on the offense lays it out. "Movers are primarily scorers. They play all over the court, from side to side and top to bottom." And "Blockers are smart team players who embrace their primary responsibility of setting good screens for movers."14 A player knows who he is before he knows where to go.

Jack Salt was a blocker, and Tony never pretended otherwise. "Jack, he's rugged, he's physical. I think I said a couple times, we want him to be a headhunter, set legal screens."15 That's a job description a big man can carry into every game, whether he scores or not.

The Bennetts put role acceptance into the culture itself. The program runs on five pillars that Dick took from scripture, humility, passion, unity, servanthood, and thankfulness.16 In his first year at Virginia, Tony gave his one-line version of servanthood.

"Whatever your role is, be a servant to the team and make your teammates better."17

"Whatever your role is." The program told players before the season that the role might be small and that serving it was the point. And Tony told recruits the same thing before they signed. His longtime assistant Ritchie McKay said Bennett "would not promise, even the best of them, that they were going to play this many minutes or have this particular role."18 Nobody showed up expecting a job the program hadn't offered.


#The tape

The Bennetts made the how something you could see. Before every Virginia practice, home or away, a student manager got down on the floor with a roll of blue tape. He ran a line across the lane, then an arc around the basket about 16 feet out. On the road they taped it in hotel ballrooms for walk-throughs. Over a season they went through hundreds of rolls.19 Luke Winn of Sports Illustrated reported that Dick had the same arc painted on the practice floor at Wisconsin.20 There's no line on a game floor that shows a defender where to stand, so the Bennetts put one there every day.

Inside that picture, the jobs are specific. Tony wrote a clinic article for the NABC in 2018, and it reads like a practice plan. On transition defense, "As we deliver a shot we immediately expect our 1 and 2 men to sprint back." The 3 man goes to the glass "if he is in a position to get to the glass," and the 4 and 5 crash.21 Every player knows his job before the shot comes down.

The drills are built the same way. In his 3-on-3 closeout drill, each defender starts with one foot in the charge circle, the coach throws the ball out, and the offense gets two dribbles. The point is "to provide maximum repetitions of basic 'Pack' techniques," which he listed as close-outs, vision, stance, on-ball discipline, and talk.21 And the standard for every rep was the same.

"We expect every pass, cut, dribble, shot, closeout, slide and repetition to be executed at game speed."21

That's a lot of teaching, and it doesn't land right away. In his first season, Tony said of his freshmen, "I don't think they have a clue defensively what it will take to play the way we need to." One of those freshmen, Joe Harris, said the footwork and positioning were "kind of tough to grasp at first."22 So the older players taught the younger ones. Mike Scott said it in 2010. "Us returners, we know what coach Bennett wants," he said. "Now we're just teaching the younger guys so they can get on our level."12

Then Tony said it in his own words.

"Through repetition and maturity you get to where you're not thinking as much."12

A year later he took it one step further. "There's a level of anticipation, as opposed to just reacting, that comes the more comfortable you get."11 A defender who isn't thinking about where to stand can see the play coming. Tony said in the NABC piece that daily attention to these building blocks "produces habits that stand up in the most pressure packed situations."21


#We value each possession

In the Bennett program, what counts is the possession. Dick said it before the 2000 Final Four. "We value each possession." And then, "I value possession of the ball. I value elimination of mistakes."3 He wasn't grading highlights. He was grading whether you gave the ball away or gave up an easy one.

Tony graded the same way, and he graded the group. In March 2015 he explained why no one player could look good alone.

"It really is a system. It's a team defensive system. Guys won't look good unless all parts are working."23

Even his drills are scored on that standard. The 3-on-3 closeout drill doesn't end on a time limit. It ends when the offense scores or the defense gets a stop, a defensive rebound or a turnover.21 When a new season opened that same fall, he gave the whole test in one question. "Can the defense outlast the offense?" Then, "That's who we are. You guys know that."24

That clarity is why Jack Salt's nights made sense to everyone. In January 2018, Virginia beat N.C. State 68-51. Salt had two points and three rebounds. In the second half he set a screen that freed Ty Jerome, who found Devon Hall for a three and a 45-25 lead.15 After the game Hall talked about the screens, not the scoring. "It is like a brick wall. Jack is extremely strong, so if he hits you with one, you are going to feel it. He takes pride in setting screens like that."25

Two points, and nobody in that locker room thought he had a quiet night. Later, when the roster changed and his minutes went down, Salt told Tony, "Coach I just want to advance. Whatever you think is best." Tony's response was to name the standard out loud. "Know your role, make others better. He embodies that. He has been the glue."16

Salt knew he was being judged on screens and toughness. So did his teammates.


#First comes discipline

The Bennett consequence has a name. Tony said it on the Inside UVA podcast.

"First comes discipline, then comes freedom."9

Players first have to master the defense and take care of the ball. Once they've shown they can do that, they earn more room to create.9 Learning research backs up that order. Slava Kalyuga's work on the expertise reversal effect found that beginners learn best with a lot of structure, while experienced learners often do better with less, because the extra structure starts to get in their way.26 The Bennetts built that into a career. A freshman gets the tape and a label. A veteran who owns them gets freedom.

The flip side was plain too. In 2011 Tony told reporters, "If you're not doing this, you're going to be falling behind."11 His players heard it. Anthony Gill said in 2015, "I didn't want my defense to be the reason why I couldn't be on the court."23 That's a player who knew exactly what happens if he doesn't. De'Andre Hunter put it even more bluntly. "We hang our hat on defense. And if you don't want to do that, this is probably not going to be the place for you."27

The enforcement was meant to come from the players. "Hopefully there's a level of accountability where Mike and Sammy and the guys who've been in the program will set the bar," Tony said in 2011.11 Gill said the same thing from the other side in 2015, talking about "holding ourselves accountable." Then he added, "The coaches can only tell us so much."24

Dick learned that lesson the hard way in his Final Four season. Wisconsin struggled in January and February, and he said afterward that the team had been "trying to please everybody." The players told him they needed to "circle these wagons, we'd better start pleasing one another."5 They went to the Final Four.

The biggest consequence in the Bennett story was a loss. In March 2018, Virginia became the first No. 1 seed to lose to a No. 16, falling to UMBC 74-54. "They thoroughly outplayed us," Tony said that night.28 He told his team, "This is life. It can't define you."18 That fall, at ACC media day, he said, "I think you have to address it," and described what Virginia was doing with it. "Owning it."29

What he didn't do was change the answers. The defense stayed the same, the roles stayed the same, and Virginia came back with the pack line under it.4 The consequence of failure in that program was never a new system. It was owning the old one harder.


#Overtime in Minneapolis

De'Andre Hunter came to Virginia and redshirted his first year. "I might as well use [the redshirt year] as a benefit instead of looking down on it," he said that January.30 When he did play, his defense is what kept him on the floor early, and his offense took months to catch up.27 Discipline first.

On April 8, 2019, Virginia played Texas Tech for the title. Hunter didn't score for the first 18 and a half minutes.31 It didn't matter, because his job never changed. He spent the last five minutes of regulation and the overtime guarding Jarrett Culver one-on-one, and Culver finished 5 of 22.31 With 12.1 seconds left in regulation and Virginia down three, Ty Jerome skipped a pass to Hunter on the wing, and Hunter tied it. He finished with a career-high 27, and Virginia won 85-77 in overtime.31

He was a defender first, and everyone knew it. Eighteen minutes without a point didn't rattle him. A stop counted as much as a basket. By April of his third year, he'd earned the freedom. So when the shot came, he took it.

Dick Bennett was in the building. He told reporters he'd come for a reason. "I thought it was more important to be here in case they lost."4 Then he said about his son, "He's so far past me. I feel like I'm back in kindergarten."4

The man who drew the line came to Minneapolis in case it didn't hold. It held.


#Notes

  1. Washington State Athletics, "Dick Bennett Profile," WSUCougars.com, undated (official biography written during his Washington State tenure). https://wsucougars.com/sports/2013/4/18/208186060 (hometown and college, high school years, Stevens Point record, the Green Bay turnaround, Green Bay's NCAA trips, the 2000 Final Four.) ↩
  2. Peter Miller (host), "#33: Coach Dick Bennett (part 1): 'All there was to the job was a love of the game and a love for the kids,'" Sport and the Growing Good podcast, April 23, 2020. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/33-coach-dick-bennett-part-1-all-there-was-to-the-job/id1497375476?i=1000472412066 (The quoted line is the episode title.) ↩
  3. "Bennett finally getting his due," Las Vegas Sun, March 23, 2000 (no byline shown, likely a wire story). https://lasvegassun.com/news/2000/mar/23/bennett-finally-getting-his-due/ (Dick Bennett on watching Lombardi's practices and on valuing each possession.) ↩
  4. Ralph D. Russo (Associated Press), "Proud pop: Former Washington State coach Dick Bennett beams as son Tony leads Virginia to NCAA Tournament title," The Spokesman-Review, April 9, 2019. https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2019/apr/09/proud-pop-former-washington-state-coach-dick-benne/ (Fran Fraschilla quote, the 2000 Final Four as Wisconsin's first in 59 years, the pack line under the title team, and both Dick Bennett quotes.) ↩
  5. Dick Bennett, NCAA Final Four press conference, Indianapolis, March 29, 2000 (ASAP Sports transcript). https://www.asapsports.com/show_interview.php?id=29137 ↩
  6. Jeff Eisenberg, "Coaching was a path Virginia's Tony Bennett once resisted and now embraces," Yahoo Sports (The Dagger), 2014 (page undated, published during the 2013-14 season). https://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/ncaab-the-dagger/coaching-was-a-path-virginia-s-tony-bennett-once-resisted-and-now-embraces-145908449.html (Tony on his father's intensity, swearing off coaching, the New Zealand player-coach job, and working for his father at Wisconsin in 1999-2000.) ↩
  7. Ben Steele, "Tony Bennett, one of top basketball players in Wisconsin history, is retiring as coach of Virginia," Milwaukee Journal Sentinel (via Yahoo Sports), October 17, 2024. https://sports.yahoo.com/tony-bennett-one-top-basketball-204417290.html (Tony's playing career.) ↩
  8. Virginia Athletics, "Tony Bennett," coach biography, VirginiaSports.com, undated. https://virginiasports.com/coach/tony-bennett (35th pick in 1992, Washington State handoff and 26-8 season, Virginia hire, and 364-136 record in 15 seasons, the most wins in school history.) ↩
  9. Andrew Ramspacher, "'Inside UVA': First Season of Podcast Wraps With Wahoo Basketball Coach Tony Bennett," UVA Today, July 6, 2022. https://news.virginia.edu/content/inside-uva-first-season-podcast-wraps-wahoo-basketball-coach-tony-bennett (Article with embedded audio and a transcript of the podcast. Source of "First comes discipline, then comes freedom," the defense-and-ball-security-before-freedom progression, and his father's influence.) ↩
  10. "Solving Basketball LIVE, BLOBs, & Dick Bennett (HV Weekly: 5/8/2020)," Hoop Vision Weekly, May 8, 2020. https://hoopvision.substack.com/p/solving-basketball-live-blobs-and (quotes from Dick Bennett's Pack Line webinar for the NABC, as reported in the newsletter.) ↩
  11. Jeff White, "Bennett Focused on Defense in Fall Workouts," VirginiaSports.com, September 27, 2011. https://virginiasports.com/news/2011/09/28/bennett-focused-on-defense-in-fall-workouts ↩
  12. Nick Eilerson, "Chasing the pack," The Cavalier Daily, November 12, 2010. https://www.cavalierdaily.com/article/2010/11/chasing-the-pack (Tony on alleys and on repetition; Mike Scott on teaching the younger players.) ↩
  13. Brett Koremenos, "Pack-Line Progeny: How Tony Bennett Used His Father's System to Turn Virginia Into an Undefeated Defensive Powerhouse," Grantland, January 14, 2015. https://grantland.com/the-triangle/virginia-defense-pack-line-dick-tony-bennett/ ↩
  14. "Dick Bennett's Blocker Mover Offense," Coach's Clipboard, undated. https://www.coachesclipboard.net/BlockerMoverOffense.html (A coaching-notes page crediting the offense to Dick Bennett; secondary source that cites no Bennett clinic material directly.) ↩
  15. Jamie Oakes, "UVA's Jack Salt has a history of spine re-aligning screens," 247Sports (TheSabre), January 15, 2018. https://247sports.com/college/virginia/Article/Virginia-Cavaliers-Basketball-UVAs-Jack-Salt-has-a-history-of-spine-re-aligning-screens-113729753/ (the headhunter quote and the N.C. State game details.) ↩
  16. Scott Wise, "5 Biblical pillars Tony Bennett used to build Virginia's Final Four team," WTVR CBS 6 (Richmond), April 5, 2019. https://www.wtvr.com/2019/04/05/tony-bennett-5-biblical-pillars (the pillars coming from Dick and from scripture, the Jack Salt minutes story, and "Know your role, make others better.") ↩
  17. "Laying a Foundation: Coach Tony Bennett discusses philosophy and goals," Virginia Magazine, November 3, 2009. https://uvamagazine.org/articles/laying_a_foundation ↩
  18. Ed Miller, "Bennettball: To get a look at UVA's all-time winningest coach, we played by his rules," Virginia Magazine, December 4, 2023. https://uvamagazine.org/articles/bennettball (the Ritchie McKay quote and "This is life. It can't define you.") ↩
  19. Jeff White, "Home or Away, Pack Line Remains a Constant," VirginiaSports.com, March 29, 2019. https://virginiasports.com/news/2019/03/29/jeff-white-pack-line (the managers, the blue tape, the 16-foot arc, hotel ballrooms, and hundreds of rolls a season.) ↩
  20. Luke Winn, "An Upset-Friendly Defense," Sports Illustrated, March 8, 2012. https://www.si.com/college/2012/03/08/an-upset-friendly-defense (the taped arc at Virginia and the painted arc at Wisconsin.) ↩
  21. Tony Bennett, "Mastering Offensive and Defensive Fundamentals," NABC Time-Out Magazine, Fall 2018 (posted on nabc.com October 23, 2018). https://nabc.com/nabc_releases/2018/bennett/ (Tony's own clinic article. Transition defense jobs, the 3-on-3 closeout drill, and the game-speed standard.) ↩
  22. Andrew Seidman, "Bennett introduces freshmen," The Cavalier Daily, October 7, 2010. https://www.cavalierdaily.com/article/2010/10/bennett-introduces-freshmen ↩
  23. Jeff White, "Hoos Rewarded for Defensive Prowess," VirginiaSports.com, March 11, 2015. https://virginiasports.com/news/2015/03/11/hoos-rewarded-for-defensive-prowess (Tony on the team defensive system; Anthony Gill on his defense.) ↩
  24. "New Season Beckons as Hoos Open Practice," VirginiaSports.com, October 1, 2015 (no byline shown). https://virginiasports.com/news/2015/10/02/new-season-beckons-as-hoos-open-practice (Tony's "Can the defense outlast the offense?" and Gill on accountability.) ↩
  25. Virginia Athletics, "No. 3 Virginia-NC State Postgame Quotes," VirginiaSports.com, January 14, 2018. https://virginiasports.com/news/2018/01/14/no-3-virginia-nc-state-postgame-quotes (Devon Hall on Jack Salt. The official transcript reads "It is like a brick wall," which differs slightly from the 247Sports version.) ↩
  26. Slava Kalyuga, "Expertise Reversal Effect and Its Implications for Learner-Tailored Instruction," Educational Psychology Review 19 (2007): 509-539. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-007-9054-3 ↩
  27. Jonathan Tjarks, "De'Andre Hunter Can Fix Virginia's Tournament Blues, If They Let Him," The Ringer, November 1, 2018. https://www.theringer.com/2018/11/01/college-basketball/deandre-hunter-virginia-profile (Hunter on defense and on the program, and his defense keeping him on the floor before his offense caught up.) ↩
  28. Scott Wise, Lane Casadonte, and Sean Robertson, "Virginia coach Tony Bennett on NCAA exit: 'We had a historic loss,'" WTVR CBS 6 (Richmond), March 17, 2018. https://www.wtvr.com/2018/03/17/tony-bennett-post-umbc ↩
  29. Chip Patterson, "How Virginia is owning the UMBC upset, plus three more things to know from ACC Media Day 2018," CBS Sports, October 24, 2018. https://www.cbssports.com/college-basketball/news/how-virginia-is-owning-the-umbc-upset-plus-three-more-things-to-know-from-acc-media-day-2018/ ↩
  30. Jeff White, "Promising Freshmen Keep Focus on Big Picture," VirginiaSports.com, January 6, 2017. https://virginiasports.com/news/2017/01/07/promising-freshmen-keep-focus-on-big-picture (Hunter on his redshirt year.) ↩
  31. Associated Press, "Comeback Cavs get their title, 85-77 in OT over Texas Tech," WCPO, April 9, 2019. https://www.wcpo.com/sports/basketball/comeback-cavs-get-their-title-85-77-in-ot-over-texas-tech (Hunter scoreless for 18 and a half minutes, his matchups with Culver, Culver 5 of 22, the tying three with 12.1 seconds left, the career-high 27.) ↩