Chapter 12
John Wooden
You Haven't Taught Until They Have Learned. How John Wooden taught at UCLA, in his own words and from the researchers who watched him work.
Chris Collinsworth · · updated · 14 min read
He thought of himself as a teacher. The researchers who sat in his gym wrote it down.
John Wooden, in his own words. From interviews, talks, his books, the researchers who sat in his practices, and the players who lived in them: Bill Walton, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Swen Nater, Andy Hill, Fred Slaughter. Sources at the end. He is the one coach in this book who was studied while he worked. Somebody wrote it down.
#Just a Teacher
John Wooden was born October 14, 1910, in Hall, Indiana, and grew up on a small farm with no electricity, doing chores before school.1 "We didn't think it was tough at the time," he said.2
His father, Joshua, gave his boys two sets of three. "Never lie, never cheat and never steal." And, "Don't whine, don't complain and don't alibi."2 Wooden carried another line from his dad for the rest of his life. "Never try to be better than someone else, always learn from others."3 He wasn't measuring himself against the other team. He was measuring himself against his best.
The family lost the farm in the Depression and moved to Martinsville, a town that loved its high school basketball.2 Wooden played in the state championship game all three years there. "We lost it twice and won it once," he said. The win was 1927.2,1
At Purdue he played guard for Piggy Lambert, whom he called "one of the most principled persons I've ever known."2 He was a three-time All-American and the national player of the year in 1932.4 He came in to study civil engineering and left with a degree in English.2
Then he did what a lot of us do. He went into a classroom. His first job was at Dayton High School in Kentucky, teaching English and coaching every sport the school had. His basketball team had a losing season, the only one of his career. Then he moved to South Bend Central, taught English, and coached basketball. In eleven years of high school coaching he went 218-42.2 He wrote his own definition of success in 1934, while he was teaching in South Bend.3
After two seasons at Indiana State, he went to UCLA in 1948.1 It took him sixteen years to win his first national title. That 1964 team went 30-0 without a starter taller than 6-foot-5, pressing all over the floor.5 By the time he retired in 1975, his teams had won 664 games, ten national championships, and 88 games in a row.1
Through all of it, he thought of himself as a teacher.
"That's all I was as a basketball coach, just a teacher."2 And he didn't think the job changed when the room did. "Coaching is teaching. Really, and that's all it is," he told NPR in 2000, and you "had to follow laws of learning."5 His biographer Seth Davis put it plainly. "He was a high school English teacher and to the day that he died, that is how he thought of himself."6
I think that's the most important thing in this book for a high school coach to hear. The best coach who ever lived thought of himself as one of us.
#Fill your role
Wooden answered that for every player on his roster, and he answered it hardest for the players who weren't going to play. He gave them a speech I've thought about a lot since I first read it.
"I tried to explain to my players that every person has a role and every role is important. You may not hardly get in the game, but your role is helping develop these players that are going to play more, and that's extremely important."2
Then he gave them a picture. "Is a powerful engine in an automobile any more important than a wheel?" he asked. "What good's that engine if you lose a wheel? What good is that wheel if you lose a nut that holds it on?" His answer was short. "So you may be just a nut, you may be just a wheel, and you may be a powerful engine."2 And then the instruction. "Fill your role."2
He didn't pretend it was easy. "I don't say it's easy to get them to accept their roles," he said, and the fix was in practice, where "you've got to pay attention to the players that aren't getting to play very much."2
The best example is how he recruited Swen Nater, a big man who had barely played high school ball. Wooden told him the truth before he ever signed.
"First, he promised that if I came to UCLA, I would not play very much because the guy ahead of me was Bill Walton, the best player in the country. Second, he promised I would compete against the best player in America every day in practice, and learn the fundamentals that I'd need."7
Think about how rare that is. Most of us recruit with playing time. Wooden recruited Nater with a job description. Nater knew exactly what he was responsible for on day one, and it wasn't minutes. It was making Walton better and getting better himself. He did both, and he later co-wrote a book with Ronald Gallimore about Wooden's teaching.7,8
Wooden drew the line around the job in time, too. He told his players that when they came on the floor each afternoon, "for the next approximately two hours, you are a basketball player." After that they were students first.2 And the job was always about his own team. "I probably scouted other teams less than any other college coach in the country," he said. "Be more concerned about your own team than the other team."2
Every player knew where he fit, and nobody had to guess whether his role mattered.
#How you put your shoes and socks on
In 1974-75, Wooden's last season, Roland Tharp and Ronald Gallimore sat in on 15 UCLA practices, about 30 hours, and logged 2,326 teaching acts, and 50.3 percent were plain instruction on what to do and how to do it.9 That's what all that instruction bought: skills that run on their own when the gym gets loud.10
It started with socks. At the first practice every season, Wooden sat his players down, All-Americans included, and showed them how to put them on. "Hold up the sock, work it around the little toe area and the heel area so that there are no wrinkles," he said. Then the shoe, spread open and pulled snug at every eyelet, and the laces double-tied.11 He wanted "your toe right at the end of the shoe so that when you stop, there's not going to be any sliding back and forth."2
Walton remembered the opening line, "Men, this is how you put your shoes and socks on," and he remembered what he thought of it. "Are you kidding me?" To a seventeen-year-old it was "this silly little old man showing us how to put on our shoes and socks!"12 It wasn't silly. A wrinkle is a blister, and a blister keeps you out of practice. "It's the little details that make the big things come about," Wooden said.11
That's what "how" looked like at UCLA. Nothing was too small to teach, and nothing was left to the player to figure out.
Wooden had a name for the method. "The 4 laws are explanation, demonstration, imitation, and repetition," he wrote, and he liked to stretch it out to eight by adding more repetitions on the end.9 The researchers saw it on the floor. He would show the right way, imitate the wrong way the player had just done it, then show the right way again.9 Right, wrong, right. The player never left with the wrong picture in his head.
Andy Hill, a bench player on three of his title teams,13 described what that sounded like.
"He taught in very quick sentences that started with him saying your name really fast. You know, he'd say, Bill or Andy. And then what would follow was a very short lesson."5
Hill's example was a pass, "I told you to put that pass to the outside hand," said over and over. "He used repetition a great deal as a teacher," Hill said.5 Gallimore wrote later that the corrections "came two or three times a minute, and each was rarely longer than 15 seconds in duration."14 Wooden got the fifteen seconds from an old coach, John Bunn, who said a coach should say what he needs to in that much time. "I wanted short things during the practice session," Wooden said.9
Short teaching took long planning. "I would spend almost as much time planning a practice as conducting it," he said, and "everything was listed on three-by-five cards down to the very last detail."9 He kept every plan in notebooks. Decades later he said he could look up a day in his first season "and tell you what we did on November the 15th."9 The researchers' summary was that "exquisite and diligent planning lay behind the heavy information load, economy of talk and practice organization."15
None of it was drilling for its own sake. Gallimore and Tharp wrote that "drill for Coach Wooden is a means to an end, not an end in itself." The goal was "automaticity or mastery of fundamentals that opens up opportunities for individual creativity and initiative."9 That's Beilock's finding from the coach's side. Drill it until the player doesn't have to think about it, and then he's free to play.
Walton saw the end of that process as a freshman. Wooden put the freshmen in the stands at Pauley to watch the varsity, and Walton was stunned by the "precision, flawless execution, incredible pace." A few minutes in, Wooden stopped everything and turned to the stands.
"From this moment on, you new players are expected to know what to do out here, and when. There will be no further explanation of what and why we are doing these things."12
That's a coach who knew when to stop explaining. Education research has a name for it. Detailed instruction that helps a beginner starts to get in the way once the learner knows the material.16 Wooden taught the freshmen everything, then expected them to know it so the practice could move.
His most famous teaching phrase is built the same way. "You have to know what to do, but you have to be quick to do it or you might not get to do it at all," he explained. "Don't hurry. You make mistakes when you hurry."17 Be quick, but don't hurry. The knowing comes first. A player who has to stop and think can't be quick.
#Two or three times a minute
Gallimore clocked Wooden's corrections at two or three a minute.14 What surprised the researchers was what kind of feedback it was. Praise was only 6.9 percent of what he said, and scolding was 6.6 percent.9 They had expected a motivator and found a teacher. Gallimore wrote that "three-quarters of the teaching statements we recorded were packed with information."14 A player at UCLA wasn't graded with "good job" or "come on." He was told what he did and what right looks like.
When Wooden did correct, he had a pattern for it. The researchers called the move a "Wooden," a short scold followed right away by the correct way to do it. Wooden called it his "sandwich approach."9 "I believe in the positive approach. Always have," he said.9 Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, remembering his coach, passed along Wooden's own description of the job. "A coach is someone who can criticize without creating resentment." Asked whether that always worked, Kareem said it did. "He knew how to do it."18
The scoreboard wasn't the grade. Wooden spent his whole career measuring something else, and he put it in one sentence.
"Peace of mind attained only through self satisfaction in knowing you made the effort to become the best of which you're capable."2
Walton said Wooden "never talked about winning and losing, but rather about the effort to win."19 And Wooden didn't believe in outside pressure as a measuring stick either. "The only pressure that amounts to a hill of beans is the pressure one puts on one's self," he said.2
That doesn't mean he didn't grade results. He did, and he was blunt about it. "I don't care how good he is if he isn't producing, it's just potential, and potential doesn't produce."2
And he tracked the inputs, player by player. His practice cards noted what part of the offense each player needed to work on and the moves for his particular position. He said he "could track the practice routines of every single player for every single practice session."9 So a UCLA player knew the standard was his best, he knew Wooden was watching the work and not just the box score, and he heard about it by name within a few seconds.
The bench players got graded too, in the place where they actually played. "The players that are getting to play a lot get praised in the papers," Wooden said. "These others, they're not getting that. You have to give it in practice."2 Hill, who spent a lot of games at the end of the bench, admitted it stung. Fans joked he was the man who started 5,000 cars at UCLA games.20 Years later he told Wooden he hadn't always given credit to the players outside the spotlight. Wooden's answer was "I'm sorry. I wish I'd done better."20 That's a coach still grading himself in his nineties.
#If you have a rule, back it up
Wooden's version of that was simple, and it was mostly off the floor.
"If you have a rule, back it up. Don't put a rule in that you're not going to back up."2
He wanted it handled right away and then dropped. Back it up, he said, "but if someone fails in some way, don't keep after them the next day. Dismiss them maybe from practice that day. Take care of it when it happens."2 Some rules were automatic. "No word of profanity or you're off the floor for the day."2 And one rule protected the whole team. "Never criticize your teammate. Never. That's unpardonable," he said. Then he told them whose job it was. "That's my job. I'm paid for it."2
His biggest consequence wasn't a speech or a punishment drill. He said a coach "has the greatest ally in the world if he isn't afraid to use it, and that's the bench."2 Players all want to play, so the bench answers without a word. Even in practice the consequence was built into the plan. The practice cards could list the number of free throws in a row a player had to make before he was allowed back into the scrimmage.9 Miss, and you keep shooting while your teammates play.
These weren't on-court reads. They were off-court rules: no beard, no profanity, no long hair, never criticize a teammate. Meant to never be broken, and backed up when they were.
The best-known test of all this came from his best player. Wooden had a rule against facial hair, and he had a reason for it. He tells the story himself.
"One day, Bill Walton came to practice wearing a beard. I said, 'Bill, have you forgotten something?' He said, 'Coach, I think I should be allowed to wear it. It's my right.' So I asked him, 'Do you believe in that strongly?' He said, 'Yes, I do, coach.' I said to him, 'Bill, I have great respect for individuals who stand up for those things in which they believe. And the team is going to miss you.'"21
Walton shaved and came back to practice.21 Years later he said, "I realized the gigantic mistakes that I had made," and "I spent the rest of my life trying to make it up to Coach Wooden."21
He handled two other players the same way when they showed up with long hair and mutton chops. They couldn't draw uniforms until they cleaned up, and he gave them a short window to decide. They went and got haircuts, and afterward they apologized. Wooden said that if he had given in, he would have lost their respect and the rest of the team's.2
Look at what's missing in those stories. There's no yelling and no argument. The rule was known ahead of time, the reason was known, and the consequence applied to the best player in the country the same as anybody else. Nobody had to wonder what would happen, so nobody had to worry about it.
#Our Eyes Meet
In the 1973 national championship game in St. Louis, UCLA played Memphis State for its seventh title in a row. Memphis State went to a zone and tied it 39-39 at halftime, then took a brief lead after the break. Walton picked up three fouls, then a fourth.22
UCLA didn't change anything. Greg Lee kept throwing lobs over the zone, and Walton kept catching them and laying them in. Lee described the whole read in eight words. "Our eyes meet and I wail it up there."22 Walton made 21 of 22 shots, scored 44 points, and grabbed 13 rebounds, and UCLA won 87-66.22 Many people still call it the greatest game ever played in a Final Four.23
Walton's job was the post. Lee's was getting him the ball. They had done it thousands of times in practices planned down to the minute on three-by-five cards. Wooden had been telling them by name, two or three times a minute, since the first day they put on their socks. The bench was right there, and nobody at UCLA was above the rules, not even Walton.
When the zone came and the fouls piled up, Lee didn't have to decide anything. Their eyes met and he threw it.
Fred Slaughter, the center on that first title team in 1964, described Wooden on game night better than I can.
"Coach Wooden basically was Cool Hand Luke. He gave us our offense, our defense, and then game time it was as though all he had to do was sit there and roll up his program and cross his legs, or whatever, watch us go to them."5
All the teaching happened during the week, so on Saturday the coach could sit there with his program rolled up. Swen Nater liked to repeat the line that became the title of his book. "As Coach used to say, 'you haven't taught until they have learned.'"7 By the time UCLA played a game, Wooden had already taught, and his players had already learned.
#Notes
- The Wooden Effect, "About Coach," undated (birth, farm, 1927 Martinsville title, Purdue, Indiana State, UCLA 1948 to 1975, 664-162, ten titles, 88 straight wins, death June 4, 2010). https://www.thewoodeneffect.com/about-coach/ ↩
- John Wooden, interview, Academy of Achievement, February 27, 1996 (farm, his father's sets of three, Martinsville, Piggy Lambert, Dayton and South Bend Central, 218-42, roles, the bench, rules, scouting, definition of success, shoes, the haircut story). https://achievement.org/achiever/john-wooden/ ↩
- John Wooden, "The Difference Between Winning and Succeeding," TED2001, February 2001. https://www.ted.com/talks/john_wooden_the_difference_between_winning_and_succeeding ↩
- Purdue Athletics, "John Wooden Statue Dedicated," PurdueSports.com, September 23, 2016. https://purduesports.com/news/2016/09/23/john-wooden-statue-dedicated ↩
- Tom Goldman, "Legendary UCLA Coach John Wooden Dies," NPR Weekend Edition Saturday, June 4, 2010. https://www.npr.org/2010/06/04/127463928/legendary-ucla-coach-john-wooden-dies Transcript: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/127463928 ↩
- Robert Siegel and Seth Davis, "John Wooden: An English Teacher Who Happened To Be A Hoops Legend," All Things Considered, NPR, January 10, 2014. https://www.npr.org/2014/01/10/261435118/john-wooden-an-english-teacher-who-happened-to-be-a-hoops-legend (Siegel interviews Davis; quotation from NPR's transcript). ↩
- Don Yaeger, "John Wooden's UCLA Player Shares Coach's Lessons And Legacy," Chief Executive, August 31, 2021 (Swen Nater on Wooden's two promises and "you haven't taught until they have learned"). https://chiefexecutive.net/john-woodens-ucla-player-shares-coachs-lessons-and-legacy/ ↩
- Swen Nater and Ronald Gallimore, You Haven't Taught Until They Have Learned: John Wooden's Teaching Principles and Practices (Morgantown, WV: Fitness Information Technology, 2006). https://fitpublishing.com/content/you-havent-taught-until-they-have-learned ↩
- Ronald Gallimore and Roland Tharp, "What a Coach Can Teach a Teacher, 1975–2004: Reflections and Reanalysis of John Wooden's Teaching Practices," The Sport Psychologist 18, no. 2 (2004): 119–137. https://doi.org/10.1123/tsp.18.2.119 The original study is Roland G. Tharp and Ronald Gallimore, "Basketball's John Wooden: What a Coach Can Teach a Teacher," Psychology Today 9, no. 8 (1976): 74–78. ↩
- Sian L. Beilock and Thomas H. Carr, "On the Fragility of Skilled Performance: What Governs Choking Under Pressure?" Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 130, no. 4 (2001): 701–725. https://doi.org/10.1037/0096-3445.130.4.701 ↩
- John Wooden as told to Devin Gordon, "John Wooden: First, How To Put On Your Socks," Newsweek, October 24, 1999. https://www.newsweek.com/john-wooden-first-how-put-your-socks-167942 (shoe and lace steps paraphrased from Wooden's account). ↩
- Tony D'Amelio, "Bill Walton: Learning to Lace My Shoes was a John Wooden Success Lesson," D'Amelio Network, July 11, 2017 (excerpt from Walton's memoir Back from the Dead, Simon & Schuster, 2016, including the freshmen in the stands at Pauley). https://blog.damelionetwork.com/sports-motivational-speaker-bill-walton-learning-to-tie-shoes-was-john-wooden-success-lesson-for-life. ↩
- Simon & Schuster, Be Quick, But Don't Hurry by Andrew Hill with John Wooden, March 13, 2001 (publisher page, Hill a UCLA reserve from 1970 to 1972). https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Be-Quick-But-Dont-Hurry/Andrew-Hill/9780743213882 ↩
- Ronald Gallimore, "What John Wooden Can Teach Us," Education Week, February 28, 2006. https://www.edweek.org/leadership/opinion-what-john-wooden-can-teach-us/2006/02 ↩
- UCLA and UC Santa Cruz, "UCLA/UC Santa Cruz study offers new perspectives on NCAA coaching legend John Wooden," EurekAlert!, June 1, 2004. https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/911495 ↩
- Slava Kalyuga, "Expertise Reversal Effect and Its Implications for Learner-Tailored Instruction," Educational Psychology Review 19 (2007): 509–539. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-007-9054-3 ↩
- Craig Impelman, "'Be Quick but Don't Hurry'," The Wooden Effect, July 24, 2019. https://www.thewoodeneffect.com/be-quick-but-dont-hurry/ ↩
- Bill Littlefield, "50 Years Of Coach Wooden And Kareem, Through Racism, Olympic Boycotts And More," Only A Game, WBUR, May 19, 2017 (Kareem Abdul-Jabbar recalling Wooden's definition of a coach). https://www.wbur.org/onlyagame/2017/05/19/john-wooden-kareem-abdul-jabbar ↩
- Tony D'Amelio, "Leadership Lessons: Bill Walton on His Favorite John Wooden Quotes," D'Amelio Network, October 25, 2016. https://blog.damelionetwork.com/2016/10/25/bill-walton-favorite-john-wooden-quotes ↩
- Tom Goldman, "When a Legendary Coach Becomes a Friend," NPR, March 29, 2007. https://www.npr.org/2007/03/29/9214883/when-a-legendary-coach-becomes-a-friend Transcript: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/9214883 ↩
- UCLA Newsroom, "Bill Walton, 71, legendary UCLA and NBA star and broadcaster, has died," May 27, 2024 (Wooden's telling of the beard story and Walton's reflections). https://newsroom.ucla.edu/stories/bill-walton-71-legendary-ucla-and-nba-basketball-player-and-sports-broadcaster-has-died ↩
- Curry Kirkpatrick, "A Slight Case of Being Superhuman," Sports Illustrated, April 2, 1973 (1973 title game, 87-66, Walton 21 of 22 for 44 points and 13 rebounds, Greg Lee's lobs, 39-39 halftime, foul trouble). https://web.archive.org/web/20250621231612/https://vault.si.com/vault/1973/04/02/a-slight-case-of-being-superhuman. The Vault article page shows no byline; author from the issue's table of contents, https://vault.si.com/vault/1973/04/02/43330-toc. ↩
- NBA.com Staff, "Legends profile: Bill Walton," NBA.com, September 13, 2021. https://www.nba.com/news/history-nba-legend-bill-walton ↩
